Super heroes are not just Soldiers in Tights with Powers

There has been a trend lately in North America to have our Superheroes kill. I find it sad, and feel that we have lost contact with what superheroes are, and why we have them. Superheroes from around the world have not changed their attitudes nearly so drastically as North American ones have. Some countries superheroes are very much based upon North American “Classic” ideology, and some have their own ideologies.

Recent “Heroes” that have immerged have been a lot more violent than I am comfortable with, and I think the one that disturbed me the most was a recent “Trans-media” series about Canadian heroes. The “Heroes of the North” is a video & comic series available online about Canadian super-soldiers. They state right in the first episodes that is what they are. They begin with origins, & have each character’s origin ending with them killing someone, sometimes a rival soldier (Non-super). But they define what I call super soldiers. They are not crime fighters, they are not there to help the population. They are created to defend the country from terrorists. That is a super-soldier. I may not like super-soldiers killing, but they do it for the defence of the country, and I don’t have to collect those comics or videos.

It really bothers me when superheroes start killing, though. Classic heroes like Batman or Superman, who both in their last reboots (Christian Bale Batman, & Man of Steel) killed. I don’t believe that any of the villains survived Batman’s wrath in those movies, and Superman would have found another way of dealing with Zod in the Man of Steel. Superheroes came out of depressions where the continent had so much crime that the regular people felt they had no hope, and were commonly committing suicide. Superheroes were people who had superpowers, sometimes that power was just caring, or money like “The Green Hornet” or “The Batman,” sometimes that actually had powers like “The Shadow” or “Superman” did. And yes, in the really old comics and radio dramas the bad guys died, but (from my research, if you see otherwise send me the cbr file) the Superhero did not kill them, they died trapped in their own evil plans. “Superheroes” are civilian, they help people. They stop criminals from hurting people, they let the justice system deal with criminals that have been stopped. They know that the moment they cross the line of killing that they are no better than the people they are trying to thwart. Superheroes don’t involve themselves in wars. The moment Superheroes act in war, they are super soldiers. And this doesn’t end well for us normals. For evidence of this take a look at Alan Moore’s “The Watchmen” or check out the movie by the same name, in which the Supers of America won the Vietnam War for the USA.

North American Super-heroes usually deal with internal problems. The Evil is human, and in modern times the evil is always major. Super heroes don’t stop crime anymore they stop super-crime. Police could stop a bank robber, Superman stops would-be-world-dominators. Where as in East Asia, the Evil is usually external, aliens, demons or monsters, almost never human. In Southeast Asia the superheroes defend the population from Supernatural evil: witches, werewolves, vampires and their like. Both East Asian and South East Asian heroes kill monsters and non-human threats to the world. They usually try not to, but to the populations of those areas, monsters need to be destroyed.

Now my experience with authentic superheroes from other countries is limited to a few sources. Cyber-6, and Captain Africa for example cover the European and African continents, but 1 hero does not a genre make. (Yes I know Cyber-6 takes place in Argentina, but it is written originally for an Italian audience). So it is hard for me to gather what the attitudes of the rest of the planet are towards Superheroes vs Super-Soldiers. I am open to learning however, if anyone wants to introduce me to a free comic (or one I can find for cheap) from the rest of the world. (And Captain Britain doesn’t count as a European Comic in my mind, as it is published by Americans for Americans).

Leave a comment